During the past 14 period, the Spanish midfielder has been largely unavailable because of an anterior cruciate ligament injury incurred against Arsenal, managing only 588 minutes for Manchester City owing to multiple relapses, the most recent of which ruled him out from the midweek 4-1 win over Borussia Dortmund in the Champions League. Even though Pep Guardiola has indicated that “his absence won’t be long-term,” the 29-year-old is essential to the manager’s philosophy. Here, we evaluate the replacements …
Nico González
“The go-to alternative when Rodri is unavailable is absolutely Nico. Nico is showing progress,” the City manager said ahead of Sunday’s 3-1 win against Bournemouth. Measuring 6ft 2in and only 23 when signed for a substantial sum from Porto in the recent transfer window, González is almost replica of Rodri. Indeed, Guardiola referred to the ex- Barcelona player as a “Rodri in the making” in the past, however in the match with Bournemouth there were times when he was pressured and lost possession in midfield in a way Rodri, in top form, would not be. That is no embarrassment, nevertheless, in failing to be in the same league as the Ballon d’Or winner.
The Croatian Veteran
The long-term loss of City’s sole other holding midfielder due to an ankle injury could be a strain for City should González also collect an injury throughout Rodri’s absence. Kovacic has performed well often for City since joining the club from Chelsea for £25m in June 2023 and boasts a resume that makes clear he is a stellar talent. The Croatian’s former clubs feature Dinamo Zagreb, Inter and Real Madrid. He also has a wealth of accolades to his name, including one La Liga title, one Premier League title and four Champions League trophies.
Lewis
Lewis has made 103 games for City, nearly a quarter of which have been as a holding midfielder. The homegrown player is skilled in the 360-vision, control, defensive work and stamina the role demands in a Guardiola-led side, but the manager has cited Lewis’s 5ft 7in height as a drawback in that role. “It’s important to have physicality, for clear reasons,” he said. “It was less [needed] in Barcelona, Bayern Munich [Guardiola’s previous clubs].” Nearing 21 soon, Lewis has time on his side and has room for development.
The Versatile Defender
“What he brings to the pitch is superb quality as a central defender and potentially as a key No 6.” That opinion expressed by Thomas Tuchel and one that echoes Guardiola concerning the ‘English defender’. Of Stones’s 408 club games, 27 have been as a holding midfielder and he shone in that role when moving forward from central defence to play next to Rodri in City’s European triumph over Inter. “The spatial awareness was the hardest for me,” Stones admitted about playing in the position. “It’s not innate – I believe I do more now, but that is thanks to learning where to take possession and how to control it in particular moments.”
The Dutch Newcomer
The Dutchman joined City from Milan this past transfer window as a replacement for Kevin De Bruyne. As he put it himself at the this year’s Club World Cup: “Playing as an attacking midfielder is why they [City] signed me. Now it’s up to me to fill the No 8 and do my best to prove that I merit a place.” As Nico recovering from a minor injury, Reijnders was deployed as a defensive midfielder in the recent 1-0 setback at Aston Villa and was shifted forward when the Spanish player came on around the 60-minute mark, the moment giving a snapshot of where he stands in Guardiola’s plans, namely as a deputy.
The Portuguese Midfielder
Born in Brazil Portugal player has only played nine matches as a holding midfielder in his career and his only appearance in the position for City occurring against Nottingham Forest in September 2023. He played the 90 minutes and delivered an assist in a 2-0 triumph.
Kalvin Phillips
Manchester City’s overlooked player is only 29. Additionally, he has operated as a deep midfielder on 164 occasions in his career and performed adequately in the role to be called up by England. Yet, it is evident he lacks the faith of Guardiola.